Wednesday, 28 May 2008

Scots Cut Class Sizes



How would you like it if your child was in a class size of 18?


I am not talking about
independent education but state education. The Scottish Government's flagship policy is to cut class sizes and this is going to cost millions of pounds. Not only will new classrooms need to be found; (maybe they grow them up there?) But teachers will have to be employed.

The Scottish Government want to achieve class sizes of 18 as a maximum in all primary levels one to three and local authorities are now attempting to achieve this according to a survey by the Association of Directors of Education in Scotland.

Some stats for you:


  • 22 of the 32 Education Authorities replied to the Scottish survey
  • An additional 2,173 teaching staff would be required which will cost £62m EVERY YEAR

  • 900 additional classrooms will be required, these will cost £360m, (obviously they do not grow them!)

  • A phased change to the catchment areas which will need to be redrawn

  • A targeted move towards the 18 class size limit

  • School extensions and/or temporary accommodation

  • Here's a good one - Two teachers allocated if class size larger !

  • A general review of school admission arrangements

This is all going before Parliament next month, in fact it will go before the education and lifelong learning and culture committee to be precise. There is no direct evidence to suggest that class sizes of 18 will lead to improved levels of attainment but it is presumed that children will get more attention and a "better disciplined environment."
"But there is no guarantee that more effective learning and teaching will result"

Class sizes has long been an issue in Scotland and in 1998 the then Scottish Office announced funding to allow progress towards a 30-pupil limit in P1 to P3. In 2007, further implementations were made to reduce class sizes to a maximum of 25 in P1 classes. In May 2007, it was decided to reduce the class sizes to an even lower level but without real educational reasons is it worth the cost?

We all know that private schools have much smaller classes but do these children succeed because their parents have a different attitude to those in some state schools. I am being incredibly general here and speaking as a parent whose children went to one school on a council estate where most could not give two figs what they little darlings were doing at school; my eldest then went to a secondary school considered one of the better schools in the area but actually not so good for her; I then sent my kids to private schools.



There is a huge difference in expectation and it is not just about class size.

No comments: