Wednesday, 28 May 2008

Scots Cut Class Sizes



How would you like it if your child was in a class size of 18?


I am not talking about
independent education but state education. The Scottish Government's flagship policy is to cut class sizes and this is going to cost millions of pounds. Not only will new classrooms need to be found; (maybe they grow them up there?) But teachers will have to be employed.

The Scottish Government want to achieve class sizes of 18 as a maximum in all primary levels one to three and local authorities are now attempting to achieve this according to a survey by the Association of Directors of Education in Scotland.

Some stats for you:


  • 22 of the 32 Education Authorities replied to the Scottish survey
  • An additional 2,173 teaching staff would be required which will cost £62m EVERY YEAR

  • 900 additional classrooms will be required, these will cost £360m, (obviously they do not grow them!)

  • A phased change to the catchment areas which will need to be redrawn

  • A targeted move towards the 18 class size limit

  • School extensions and/or temporary accommodation

  • Here's a good one - Two teachers allocated if class size larger !

  • A general review of school admission arrangements

This is all going before Parliament next month, in fact it will go before the education and lifelong learning and culture committee to be precise. There is no direct evidence to suggest that class sizes of 18 will lead to improved levels of attainment but it is presumed that children will get more attention and a "better disciplined environment."
"But there is no guarantee that more effective learning and teaching will result"

Class sizes has long been an issue in Scotland and in 1998 the then Scottish Office announced funding to allow progress towards a 30-pupil limit in P1 to P3. In 2007, further implementations were made to reduce class sizes to a maximum of 25 in P1 classes. In May 2007, it was decided to reduce the class sizes to an even lower level but without real educational reasons is it worth the cost?

We all know that private schools have much smaller classes but do these children succeed because their parents have a different attitude to those in some state schools. I am being incredibly general here and speaking as a parent whose children went to one school on a council estate where most could not give two figs what they little darlings were doing at school; my eldest then went to a secondary school considered one of the better schools in the area but actually not so good for her; I then sent my kids to private schools.



There is a huge difference in expectation and it is not just about class size.

Monday, 26 May 2008

Prep Schools In Under Fives Revolt

The Independent Schools Council (ISC), which represents 1,280 fee-paying schools educating more than 500,000 children, has decided to stand up and be counted. Beverley Hughes, the Children’s Minister, has been written to and told that the under-fives "are subject to greater government interference than that of any other age group." She has also been told in no uncertain terms that the new national curriculum for the under-fives, violates parents’ human rights by denying them the freedom to choose how they educate their children.

A leaked copy of the letter has been seen by The Times. Oh lucky private schools who can at least opt to opt out of any curriculum.

State schools are stuck with the whole bureaucratic hell. For further reading on the independent schools angst in the Times: http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/education/article4004420.ece


The new framework will assess children - Sorry, will mean that TEACHERS, TAs, CHILD CARE WORKERS, CHILDMINDERS? will be assessing up to 500 developmental milestones that occur between birth and primary school. This stupid framework expects the under-fives to be assessed on 69 writing, problem solving and numeracy skills. Yet more paperwork and more tests when under fives should only be at school to play. Five-year-olds should not be stressed and if my children were that age now I would be sending them to a school that opts out of these tests even if I had to pay.


Ed Balls so suits his name.

Green Schools? No Way Says Ofsted

Ofsted are not happy again.

Schools are failing to teach children to be green and are treating environmental awareness as a peripheral issue.

Inspectors have found that the majority of schools they visited did not pay enough attention to sustainable development and that “Ethical purchasing was usually confined to buying Fairtrade products for the staff room". Schools have been praised for certain areas such as 'imaginative projects and excellent teaching on sustainability but there is much to do and it is generally uncoordinated

National Union of Teachers, rep Christine Blower said: “Far too few schools are teaching about the biggest issue facing the planet. Schools are over-burdened with a range of excessive and unreasonable external demands. This makes it harder to focus on teaching climate change and sustainability.”
Ofsted recommended that the Government should give higher priority to sustainability in schools, support this through funding, and ensure that the curriculum reflected the importance of the subject.

The Government wants all schools to become sustainable by 2020, as part of its ambitious £45billion Building Schools for the Future programme, which will rebuild or refurbish all schools in the country. (The school where I am a governor being one of them!)

What makes me laugh is that Ofsted talk of how green they wish our schools to be yet playing fields are still being sold off by THIS government. Admittedly this has slowed down in comparison to the debacle of the Tory government which sold off any land it could lay its hands on. That was a travesty. Sadly this government thinks it is better because it has slowed down and thinks this is the only answer. It is not and Ofsted is there for a reason and I hope inspectors are listened too.

SNP And Free PT


The Scottish National Party has come up with a corker of an idea and if only this be pulled off for EVERY child in the whole of the UK. Every child in Scotland is to be given a week of free outdoor adventure education, under government plans. This idea is being suggested as a way to boost confidence, develop leadership skills, improve educational attainment and curb obesity by encouraging children to take more exercise and to divert wayward youngsters from criminal activity.

The SNP will be announcing this idea next month and the thoughts are that all 11-year-olds will be offered a five-day adventure break with activities such as kayaking, climbing and abseiling, to help them to learn team-building skills before they start secondary school. This is a great idea as it helps that gap between primary and secondary education and it is said that some high flying students tend to fall behind at this juncture and get into trouble with anti-social behaviour.

Children in the most deprived areas will be given the opportunity to involved in this scheme before being rolled out across the country. The cost factor would be £10m to house 53,000 pupils for a week each year and currently Scotland's four outdoor centres provide training for 20,000 kids.
“We are committed to improving outdoor learning for children,” said a spokeswoman for the Scottish government. “It promotes cross-curricular learning as well as encouraging physical activity.
“Our new framework for learning and teaching, which Fiona Hyslop, education minister, will launch on June 10, will set out further details.”

My concern is that if the current outdoor centres house 20,000 children have they the resources for the extra children and has this been thought out?

Gavin Hastings, the former Scotland rugby international, said he supported an expansion of outdoor education opportunities for children. “At the moment we are sorely lacking something like this in too many of our schools — a scheme that encourages both personal development and physical activity,” he said.
Many outdoor centres have closed in recent years due to a lack of funding. However, Scottish Outdoor Education Centres, the umbrella body for the sector, claims that existing facilities could be easily upgraded at a reasonable cost to cater for the new scheme.
“Residential outdoor learning is a powerful way to help prepare children and young people to meet future challenges,” said a spokesman.
“It can provide the qualities, skills and knowledge that children and young people need to succeed in the world of work and to engage effectively in society.”
Scottish Tories have endorsed the campaign by basically calling for an expansion in the provision of outdoor education. No news from Scottish Labour.

As I said, if only this was a national idea and all parents were encouraged to allow their little darlings to disappear off for a week and learn to become young people.

Great idea by the SNP.

Appealling Appeals In Durham, Appalling Appeals In Fulham


Thanks to the Guardian for this article.

Parents face a postcode lottery in their chances of successfully appealing for a place for their child at a popular school, figures revealed last Friday.


As more than 50,000 families contest a school place for this year, official figures for last year reveal wild differences between the success rates of appeals in different local authorities.

London authorities where competition for good school places is among the toughest in the country have the lowest success rates - 2.5% in Hammersmith and Fulham and 2.8% in Westminster. In comparison, in North Lincolnshire 81.1% of appeals are successful. In Rotherham 75.1% of appeals succeed and in Durham 76.8%.


Ministers will shortly receive a report by the schools adjudicator on a review of appeal panels. It comes amid concern about the fairness of appeals. Philip Hunter was asked to investigate the extent to which some panels may be bending the laws for parents or failing to stick to their code.
The review will inform a consultation on admissions and appeals to be published by ministers in the next month.


Jim Knight, the schools minister, told the Guardian variation was inevitable in a system that has 150 local authorities and countless schools setting their own admissions criteria. "If there's some variety that might reflect some differences in aspirations from parents, but it's as likely or more likely to reflect differences in practices in terms of how admissions authorities have been administrating the admissions system."

A code of admissions being introduced this year would aim to make the system fair. "The very small proportion of appeals heard, compared to the overall number of admissions processed, shows the system works well - 98% of primary admissions offers and over 94% of secondary do not have any appeal heard against them."
Knight hoped the variation between authorities would narrow with the new code, but said it would still be affected by factors including how appeals are administered, the level of ambition among parents and the range of schools.


Last year there was shift in appeals from secondary school to primary school places. A total of 39,230 families appealed over a secondary place, 2,000 more than the year before. Meanwhile 17,360 appeals were launched for primary places, a 26% increase. Overall, 19,450 appeals were decided in favour of parents, more than 1,000 fewer than the previous year.
Nick Gibb, the shadow schools minister, said: "One in five parents fail to get their first choice of secondary school and the number of appeals is rising.
"Poorer parents are worst hit because there are fewer good schools in disadvantaged areas ... All parents should have the power that now only richer parents have - the power to choose their school."


David Laws, the Liberal Democrat spokesman for education, said: "Parents trying to get their children into high quality schools are feeling increasingly frustrated. This is an indication of Labour's failure to raise school standards across the board - and to tackle the dramatic inequalities in outcomes between different schools and different neighbourhoods."

Win or lose
Bottom 15 places where you are least likely to win a school place on appeal (% appeals heard which were successful 2006-7)
Hammersmith and Fulham 2.5
Westminster 2.8
North Somerset 2.9
Solihull 4.9
Wandsworth 5.4
Kensington and Chelsea 6.1
Reading 7.4
Kingston upon Thames 7.7
Bromley 7.9
Waltham Forest 8.6
Merton 9.5
Camden 9.8
Lambeth 9.8
Ealing 9.8
Harrow 10.1

Top 15 places where you are most likely to win a school place on appeal
North Lincolnshire 81.1
Durham 76.8
Rotherham 75.1
Derbyshire 74.6
Cornwall 69.5
Walsall 66.9
Cambridgeshire 66.5
Wigan 65.8
Redcar and Cleveland 65.3
Sunderland 63.9
Knowsley 62.5
Bath and north-east Somerset 62.1
Dorset 62.0
Nottinghamshire 62.0
Somerset 61.8

The Tyranny Of Testing - Book Review


Warwick Mansell, TES staff reporter has written a book which looks at the effects of the results-driven teaching, with suggestions for alternatives. The Publisher is Politico's and it is available in hardback at a price of £19.99 ISBN: 9781842751992. URL: http://www.politicospublishing../

Testing has been a hot issue in news over the past couple of weeks. It will continue while the GCSEs and AS and A2s are sat. The poor kids who have worked hard will feel demoralised while stupidity takes over the supposed intelligent adults argue over their O Levels were of a higher standard than these youngsters exams. My daughter has her first GCSE next month, one year early, she has already taken one paper and scored 100% and she did that by revising and working hard not by sitting back and doing nothing. but I digress, here is a link to a review of Warwick's book by Colin Richards. If you like what you see, why not get the book? http://www.tes.co.uk/reviewbank/product.aspx?productId=2413&title=Education%20by%20Numbers:%20The%20Tyranny%20of%20Testing

Cruel Summer


Do you remember those glorious days of the summer holidays, when we used to go out as soon as we slung on our clothes, put a sandwich, or maybe even real breakfast in our mouths?

The centre-left thinktank, Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR), has suggested that times have changed and yes we know this, and on paper the idea sounds OK apart from one thing the SUMMER HOLIDAY. An option could be to divide the school year into five eight-week terms, with a fortnight's holiday between each and a five week summer holiday. NO cry the kids. I wonder what many working parents would be saying though? For working parents childcare costs become the problem and I understand that. I am a school governor and have been for ten years and a parent of two fast growing children.


Where I live we had meetings some years ago to discuss the five term year and it was decided we required information and research. WE had parents who work and those who do not and it was a dilemma because the cost factor was an issue working ones needed to deal with and most still felt shortening the holiday was NOT the answer. This is the FIRST piece of factual information that has been produced since the government suggested five terms to Local Education Authorities - I think it was four years ago, it may be longer but the time escapes me. This research suggests that the traditional academic year does not help children and it needs an overhaul to stop them falling behind in class. According to a report to be published today.


Research suggests pupils are losing some of their reading skills during the long summer break, it would allow pupils to sustain their education more easily over the year.

While I realise that kids nowadays do not have the freedom that we used to have, there is no reason for them not too. It is only us the parents stopping them because of the terrible things we read. There is actually no increase in child abductions and the only real issue is accidents which happen because are kids are not street savvy. Maybe instead of organising holiday clubs where structure is the norm, or children should be allowed to go out and build dens, make bow and arrows, climb trees, scrap their knees and yes sometimes they might break an arm but that is called LEARNING. It is also called social skills which they do not always learn at school as they are too busy with SATs and the ever changing curriculum.

I disagree. My children learn so much in their summer break. They learn friendship, they learn to use their skills learned at school in a practical sense which is fantastic for them as they are both dyslexic and learn better using this approach. They also need to learn through boredom. Boredom is how imaginations grow! How many people reading this remember saying "I'm bored", and then going off and doing something exciting? (Hopefully not illegal!) Our children need to explore their childhood because right now they do not have one. We all say that kids grow up too fast and this is the reason - NO CHILDHOOD. We take away their rightful summer break and we kill their chance of freedom, exploration and and true chance to wind down from school. They need it as much as the staff who teach them.

There is no doubt that the current curriculum is too narrow, the school year, inflexible and children fall through the net. But this research is flawed and totally biased towards a government which is making schools a centre of social welfare and turning teachers into social workers.

Look to Scandinavia where children start school at 6/7 and have approx 11 weeks off for their summer holidays. Their learning ability is much higher than our children's. They leave school with better exam qualifications so is shortening the summer break the answer?