MPs are being told that Universities should receive extra money if they increase their proportion of students they gain from less well-off backgrounds, so says the Office of Fair Access.Sir Martin Harris, the head of the university access watchdog has stated that this would apparently help universities to attract students from low-income families who are still under-represented in higher education. So has now been presented in front of the innovation, universities, science and skills committee where MPs have been asking Harris how universities could become more socially adaptable.
He has some solutions but whether these will work are debatable. One idea is for universities to employ staff to work with 16-year-olds on skills that would help them get university places. These staff members would have to have excellent people skills and be brilliant 'youth mentors' as they would also have to tell these teens that they were good enough to apply to a good university. Being a parent of a teen and pre-teen I know the roller coaster of hormones and would not like to work day in day out with them! (Bless them).
Some MPs suggested that universities should be fined if they did not admit a minimum number of students from the poorest families. Harris disagreed with these MPs and said; "We should encourage every university to make sure its pool of applicants is as socially representative as possible," he said. "But universities respond better to carrots than sticks."
However, Labour MP for Durham, Roberta Blackman-Woods, disagreed, saying there had to be something to push universities to take a bigger pool of students from disadvantaged backgrounds.
Phil Willis, Liberal Democrat MP for Harrogate and Knaresborough, added: "Unless there is some sort of stick, how will it happen?"
Harris said: "I fundamentally don't agree that universities discriminate against a student's social class; it's that [the most economically deprived students] aren't in the pool
of applicants.
"It's not clear to me that it is principally universities who should be talking to five- or eight-year-olds. How far should universities go down the route of supplementing the pastoral care of teachers? We have to change what 11-year-olds think they are capable of. That can only be part of a societal decision."
However, Labour MP for Durham, Roberta Blackman-Woods, disagreed, saying there had to be something to push universities to take a bigger pool of students from disadvantaged backgrounds.
Phil Willis, Liberal Democrat MP for Harrogate and Knaresborough, added: "Unless there is some sort of stick, how will it happen?"
Harris said: "I fundamentally don't agree that universities discriminate against a student's social class; it's that [the most economically deprived students] aren't in the pool
of applicants."It's not clear to me that it is principally universities who should be talking to five- or eight-year-olds. How far should universities go down the route of supplementing the pastoral care of teachers? We have to change what 11-year-olds think they are capable of. That can only be part of a societal decision."
Understand that? Good, then I shall move on.
It was announced in April that all universities will have to submit details of their admissions procedures to a government body to reassure students that their applications are fairly treated. John Denham,the universities secretary, said universities could face financial penalties if they were proved to have unfair policies. Sir Martin Harris said that MPs and the government should not interfere in universities' admissions policies by forcing them to publish their entry procedures. The media will get hold of the admissions information because having everything 'open and honest' means things will be manipulated and not seen honestly.
Thank goodness there will NOT be fines for universities who do not meet their remit on numbers because that could dumb down the educational value of higher education. There are reasons why more privately educated children succeed to gain entry into the best universities and I can use me as an example. I went to the worst comprehensive in my town, in fact one of the worst in my county. I do not know how many eventually went on to uni but I think six or seven girls and boys went on to become parents within nine months of leaving at 16.
I would had loved to go to university but I came from a poorer family. I was born in 1970, my parents were not very aspirational but worked hard in their working class jobs. They both went to boarding schools but mum because her dad was in the army and hers was an army boarding school and dad went to The Royal Alexandra and Albert School; a state boarding school for kids in care or kids who had lost a parent in the war which dad had. Dad got kicked out for bootlegging and general disorder, he was a naughty boy and mum left just before her O levels as her father left the army so both my parents had to go to 'normal' schools in the state sector at the ages of 14/15. They both failed their exams. I was bullied throughout my education, I like my parents had low self esteem and
did horrendously in my education at school even though at the age of 11 I wanted to be a Neurosurgeon. So university was a dream for me which was not going to happen at 18 because my parents could not afford it and I did not believe in myself anyway.
did horrendously in my education at school even though at the age of 11 I wanted to be a Neurosurgeon. So university was a dream for me which was not going to happen at 18 because my parents could not afford it and I did not believe in myself anyway.I'm now 38 and a mother of two. I took one child out of state education last Easter and the other last September. The eldest will be staying in private education at least till her GCSEs and then probably move to the local sixth form college as it is a particular good one. The youngest child is in a local prep school and in 2009 will move as a day boy to a public school I never thought in a million years he would be able to go to. I do not expect my kids to go to university/higher education, but I do expect to offer this opportunity to them should they want it. We are aspirational and moving to private education has given us a totally different insight into an amazing world we never expected to see.
There is a reason why privately educated kids get into university over poorer families. It is more about expectations and not always about money.
